More Evidence for the Three-Man Rotation

Effects of varying recovery periods on muscle enzymes, soreness, and performance in baseball pitchers, by Potteiger, Blessing, and Wilson, Journal of Athletic Training, 1992; 27(1): 27–31.

From the Abstract

Results indicate that muscle damage, as evidenced by CK release, occurs in response to baseball pitching. However CK values, muscle soreness, and pitch velocity are not significantly affected by changes in the amount of recovery time typically scheduled between games.

The authors look at a sample of pitchers and how they recover after pitching different lengths of time. The results show a few things. First, the pattern of recovery indicates most healing occurs soon after pitching, and that further recovery occurs at a diminishing rate. After three days of rest, the measures of skeletal muscle damage were back to baseline values. Second, performance on two days of rest is only slightly worse than, and not statistically distinguishable from, performance on four days of rest. This is good news for the Phillies and Roy Oswalt. The results are also consistent with my analysis (with Sean Forman) of major-league pitchers.

You can get the gist of the results from the graphs in the pages below. The study is short, interesting, and it’s not even new. There a lot of studies in the fields of sports medicine, exercise physiology, and sports science that look at popular sabermetric questions. If you have a sabermetric question, it won’t hurt to do a PubMed search on the topic.

6 Responses “More Evidence for the Three-Man Rotation”

  1. Neil says:

    You really need to send this study to Tim “waste of space” McCarver. He just spent almost a half an inning talking about how there’s never been a study done on the impact of pitching on short rest.

  2. JC says:

    In Tim’s defense, it’s not like our study has been widely circulated. And, it hasn’t been published in a peer-reviewed journal yet. That’s one of the reasons we conducted it. I hope others will find it useful to answer this question.


  1. […] This post was mentioned on Twitter by J.C. Bradbury, Andy Beard. Andy Beard said: RT @jc_bradbury: More Evidence for the Three-Man Rotation […]

  2. […] Bradbury links to a paper showing biological evidence that teams should go to a three-man rotation in the playoffs: The authors look at a sample of pitchers and how they recover after pitching different lengths of […]

  3. […] I agree with McCarver that you should use your three best starters exclusively in the postseason, but he stated there haven't been any studies. There have been, J.C. Bradbury linked to one last week. […]

  4. […] what Tim McCarver said during Saturday night’s Game 3, here’s statistical backing for using a three-man rotation in the playoffs. And in other counterintuitive statistical analysis, Peter Keating argues that it is possible to […]